Wikimedia Commons1587-1590; ongoing as foundational American mysteryFolklore SiteLegend
Roanoke IslandAmerican Folklore Mythology
The colony that vanished in 1590, leaving only the word CROATOAN carved into a post — America's oldest unsolved mystery
Images via Wikimedia Commons
The Myth
In 1587, 117 English colonists — men, women, and children — established a settlement on Roanoke Island under Governor John White. When White returned to England for supplies and was delayed three years by the Anglo-Spanish War, he came back in 1590 to find the colony abandoned. Every person was gone. The buildings had been dismantled. The only clue was the word CROATOAN carved into a wooden post, and the letters CRO carved into a nearby tree.
Croatoan was the name of a nearby island (modern Hatteras Island) and the Croatoan people who lived there. White believed the colonists had moved to Croatoan, but storms prevented him from searching. He never returned.
The Lost Colony became the founding mystery of American settlement — the story that says the continent swallowed the first people who tried to claim it. It has been retold, reimagined, and mythologized for over 400 years. The Lost Colony outdoor drama, performed on Roanoke Island since 1937, is the longest-running outdoor symphonic drama in the United States.
Want more like this?
The Weekly Myth hasn't started yet: one sacred site a week, its myth and its history. Leave your email and we'll write when the first one goes out.
We'll only use your email for the Weekly Myth. Unsubscribe anytime.
Themes
The Place
Roanoke Island is a 12-mile-long island in the Outer Banks of North Carolina, between the mainland and the barrier islands. The Fort Raleigh National Historic Site preserves the approximate location of the 1587 settlement, including an earthwork fort reconstructed based on archaeological evidence.
The island is connected to the mainland by bridge and to the Outer Banks by the Virginia Dare Memorial Bridge. Manteo, the island's main town, is named for a Croatoan man who traveled to England with earlier Roanoke expeditions.
The History
The Roanoke colonies were part of Sir Walter Raleigh's effort to establish English footholds in North America. The 1585 colony (a military venture) had already alienated the local Secotan and Croatoan peoples through violence and food seizures. The 1587 colony was intended as a civilian settlement, but inherited the tensions of its predecessor.
Modern archaeology and genetic research have proposed several theories: that the colonists dispersed among local tribal nations, that they moved to the Chesapeake Bay area and were later killed, or that they fragmented into multiple groups. Archaeological finds at Hatteras Island (Site X) have yielded European artifacts in Native American contexts dating to the right period, supporting the integration theory.
Virginia Dare, born August 18, 1587, was the first English child born in the Americas. She was among the vanished. Her name has been attached to a bridge, a county, a memorial, and a brand of wine.
Frequently Asked
117 colonists vanished from Roanoke Island in 1590, leaving only the word CROATOAN carved into a post — the oldest unsolved mystery in American history and the founding myth of a continent that swallowed its first claimants.
Sources
Quinn, David Beers. Set Fair for Roanoke: Voyages and Colonies, 1584-1606 (1985). University of North Carolina Press. Quinn's life work synthesised — the definitive academic history of the Roanoke voyages, drawing on Hakluyt, the Spanish archives, and the John White papers. The standard scholarly reference on the Lost Colony.
Tier 2Horn, James. A Kingdom Strange: The Brief and Tragic History of the Lost Colony of Roanoke (2010). Basic Books. Modern narrative synthesis by the President of the Jamestown Rediscovery Foundation. Integrates Site X archaeological evidence supporting the colonist-integration theory.
Tier 2Hakluyt, Richard. The Principal Navigations, Voyages, Traffiques and Discoveries of the English Nation (1600). George Bishop, Ralph Newberie, and Robert Barker, London. View source → Hakluyt's compilation includes John White's first-person narrative of the 1590 return to Roanoke and the discovery of CROATOAN carved on the post. The earliest published primary source.
Tier 1Related Entries
Mothman Bridge
The Silver Bridge collapse and the Mothman sightings that preceded it
West Virginia, United States
Spook Hill
A stretch of road in central Florida where cars appear to roll uphill — explained by the Seminole as the resting place of a great alligator killed in battle
Florida, United States
Donner Pass
The specific mountain pass and lakeside campsite where 87 emigrants were trapped by snow in the winter of 1846-47 — and 36 of them died
California, United States
Devils Tower
The igneous monolith sacred to over 20 tribal nations, known to the Lakota as Mato Tipila — Bear Lodge
Wyoming, United States
Mythic Grounds acknowledges that many sites documented here are sacred to Indigenous peoples and living cultural communities. We strive to present information respectfully, drawing only from published and authorized sources. If you are a member of a community represented on this site and believe any content is inaccurate or culturally inappropriate, please contact us.