Wikimedia CommonsWinter of 1846-47Folklore SiteLegend
Donner PassAmerican Folklore Mythology
The specific mountain pass and lakeside campsite where 87 emigrants were trapped by snow in the winter of 1846-47 — and 36 of them died
Images via Wikimedia Commons
The Myth
The Donner Party is America's definitive survival horror story, and it is all true.
In the fall of 1846, a group of 87 emigrants — families, mostly, with children — took an untested shortcut through the Wasatch Mountains and the Great Salt Lake Desert, losing weeks and cattle. By the time they reached the Sierra Nevada in late October, early snow had sealed the pass. They were trapped.
The party split into two camps: one at the east end of Donner Lake, the other at Alder Creek, six miles to the north. They built rough shelters. They ate their oxen, then their horses, then their dogs, then boiled hides and bones into glue. By December, people were dying.
A group of fifteen — later called the Forlorn Hope — set out on snowshoes to cross the pass and reach help in the Sacramento Valley. Seven survived, partially by eating the dead. Rescue parties eventually reached the lake camp and found survivors living among the remains of the dead. Of the 87 original members, 36 died.
The story crystallized something in the American imagination: the West will kill you. The land does not care. The mountain does not want you here.
Want more like this?
The Weekly Myth hasn't started yet: one sacred site a week, its myth and its history. Leave your email and we'll write when the first one goes out.
We'll only use your email for the Weekly Myth. Unsubscribe anytime.
Themes
The Place
Donner Pass (elevation 7,056 feet) is the mountain pass through the Sierra Nevada where Interstate 80 now crosses between Reno and Sacramento. Donner Lake sits in the valley directly below the pass, a blue alpine lake 3 miles long.
The Donner Memorial State Park preserves the eastern lakeside campsite. The Emigrant Trail Museum at the park contains artifacts and a detailed account of the ordeal. A large stone pedestal near the museum marks the campsite — its base is 22 feet tall, representing the depth of snow that winter.
The Alder Creek campsite — where the Donner family camped separately — is six miles north, on private land managed by the U.S. Forest Service. It was archaeologically excavated in the 2000s.
The History
The Donner Party left Springfield, Illinois in April 1846 as part of a larger wagon train. They separated from the main group at Fort Bridger, Wyoming, taking the unproven Hastings Cutoff on the advice of promoter Lansford Hastings, who had never actually taken the route with wagons.
The shortcut cost them a month. They reached the Sierra in late October with early storms already dropping snow. The party was trapped from November 1846 to April 1847.
Archaeological work at Alder Creek by the University of Oregon (2003-2006) and at the lake camp by earlier excavations confirmed the campsites and recovered artifacts but found less evidence of cannibalism than the popular narrative suggests. The cannibalism at the Forlorn Hope and at the lake camp is well-documented from survivor accounts; its extent at Alder Creek is less certain.
The name 'Donner' now belongs to the lake, the pass, the memorial park, the ski resort, and the local school. The family's name became the landscape.
Frequently Asked
The mountain pass where 87 emigrants were trapped by snow in the winter of 1846 — America's definitive survival story, preserved at a lakeside memorial with a pedestal 22 feet tall, the depth of the snow.
Sources
Rarick, Ethan. Desperate Passage: The Donner Party's Perilous Journey West (2008). Oxford University Press. The standard modern academic narrative of the Donner Party, integrating survivor accounts, military rescue records, and recent archaeological evidence.
Tier 2Johnson, Kristin (ed.). Unfortunate Emigrants: Narratives of the Donner Party (1996). Utah State University Press. Edited compilation of the primary survivor narratives — the Reed family, the Breen diary, the Eddy account — that form the documentary basis for everything since.
Tier 1Dixon, Kelly J., Julie M. Schablitsky, and Shannon A. Novak (eds.). An Archaeology of Desperation: Exploring the Donner Party's Alder Creek Camp (2011). University of Oklahoma Press. Peer-reviewed archaeological volume reporting on the 2003-2006 University of Oregon and University of Montana excavations at the Alder Creek camp. Re-examines the cannibalism narrative on physical evidence.
Tier 2Collections
Related Entries
Mothman Bridge
The Silver Bridge collapse and the Mothman sightings that preceded it
West Virginia, United States
Sleepy Hollow
The Dutch colonial village where Washington Irving's Headless Horseman rides — and where the real history is stranger than the fiction
New York, United States
Roanoke Island
The colony that vanished in 1590, leaving only the word CROATOAN carved into a post — America's oldest unsolved mystery
North Carolina, United States
The Jersey Devil Birthplace
The Pine Barrens homestead where Mother Leeds gave birth to her 13th child — and it flew up the chimney
New Jersey, United States
Mythic Grounds acknowledges that many sites documented here are sacred to Indigenous peoples and living cultural communities. We strive to present information respectfully, drawing only from published and authorized sources. If you are a member of a community represented on this site and believe any content is inaccurate or culturally inappropriate, please contact us.